Jim Edmonds Ends Unofficial Retirement, Signs With Brewers

Yesterday, I talked about Jim Thome and whether or not he will be a Hall of Famer five years after he retires. The Thome HOF debate is certainly a fascinating one.

Another potential HOF candidate that will strike up a debate five years after he retires is outfielder Jim Edmonds.

One of Edmonds' many great catches

Edmonds is known as one of the better defensive center fielders of all-time. His acrobatic catches are stuff of legend. I still believe his back to the ball, giving catch against the Kansas City Royals as a member of the California/Anaheim Angels is the best catch I have ever seen by a center fielder.

Offensively, Edmonds has quietly amassed 384 home runs, a .284 average, and a .377 OBP. He is a four-time All Star and has two, top-five MVP finishes in his 16 year career.

It’s a classic argument of is the player SO great defensively, that it elevates him to HOF status even though his offensive numbers might not be there?

If you ask most St. Louis Cardinal fans, they will tell you Edmonds is a first-ballot HOF’er. The reality is, while Edmonds has had a nice career, the only way he will ever see the inside of Cooperstown will be if he goes with his family on a visit.

Now, I am sure I will get some less-than-friendly comments from Cardinal fans telling me how Edmonds is worthy of HOF consideration. Of course, it wouldn’t be a normal day without Cardinal fans crying or whining about something.

But Edmonds is not a HOF’er. He doesn’t have the offensive numbers. They are not even close. Defensively, while Edmonds was great, was he better than Devon White, Torii Hunter, or Andruw Jones?

The reason why Brooks Robinson and Ozzie Smith made and Omar Vizquel will make the HOF is because they were so much better defensively than anyone else who ever played their position. You can’t say that about Edmonds.

Whether you believe Edmonds is a HOF’er or not, there is no denying he was a very good player, for a good period of time. I thought Edmonds was going to be forced into retirement after not playing the entire 2009 season, but Edmonds isn’t done yet.

According to Tim Haudricourt of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, via Twitter, the Milwaukee Brewers have signed the Fullerton, CA native to a minor league contract. Edmonds can make $850,000 if he makes the team and another $1.65 million in incentives.

Edmonds last played in the majors in 2008 with the San Diego Padres and the Chicago Cubs. It looked like his career might have been over with the Padres after hitting only .178 with one home run in 26 games.

Edmonds was released and found is second wind with the Cubs and was really good for them. He hit .256 with 19 home runs and had a .937 OPS in just 86 games. He certainly gave the Cubs a spark and helped them to the best record in the National League.

Why the Cubs or any other team for that matter didn’t at least give Edmonds a shot to make the team in 2009 always was a mystery to me. A team could have certainly used him against righties in a pinch-hitting role.

If Edmonds makes the Brewers out of spring training, he could be used in a pinch-hitting role against righties and a fourth outfielder. Edmonds really slipped defensively in 2008 (-14.1 UZR), so I would doubt the Brewers would use him in a platoon with newly acquired center fielder Carlos Gomez.

The Brewers have to grant Edmonds his release if he’s not on the major league roster by March 25th.

You can follow The Ghost of Moonlight Graham on Twitter @ thghostofmlg

Tags: , , , , , ,

5 Responses to “Jim Edmonds Ends Unofficial Retirement, Signs With Brewers”

  1. Dave Says:

    Good article. I need to add Edmonds to my HoF watch. I don’t think he’ll ever be elected, but he could top the 5% threshold and stay on the ballot awhile. .905 OPS and 8 GGs for a CF should be worth something.

  2. Phil Says:

    This entire article is nothing more than a very weak strawman.

    I don’t know a single Cardinal fan beliving Edmonds had an HOF career. He needed at least 4 more years of top production to be seriously considered. I’m thinking your issues with Cardinal fans has little to do with the actual content of your articles. I seriously doubt Cardinal fans care one way or the other on what you think if all your artcles build a premise you assign to others simply so you can knock down the premise you created.

  3. Tom Spirakis Says:

    As “The Resident Cardinals Fan” I have to say I do not think Edmonds is a HOF’er. I was sure he would be, but the rapid decline in his production after 2006 has left me pretty sure it will never happen. He’s going to be one of those guys (Mattingly, Murphy, Parker) who stay on the ballot forever. I’d love to see it happen but I don’t think so.

    While I realize I am partially to blame for your hatred towards Cardinal fans I think it is completely off the mark. You should appreciate passionate fans, who give a crap about there team and actually follow baseball in general. You and I know far too many fans who only follow the home team’s parade route, and couldn’t tell you anything about any of the other 29 teams in baseball. That is not the case with Cardinals fans.

    Let’s not forget to “cry” a little while I’m here. Why in the world didn’t the Cards give Jimmy Ballgame the same deal. They need a 4th and/or 5th OF, they have a fairly inexperienced CF and are desperate for a left-handed bat off the bench. Add into it, veteran leadership, a fan favorite and a guy really deserving of another shot and it seems like a perfect match.

  4. Buddy Says:

    Edmonds is :one of the better defensive CF of all time”? He was certainly good, but that’s a bit strong, don’t you think?

    • Adam Bernacchio Says:

      Hey Buddy,

      I don’t think that is a bit strong. I think if we came up with a list of the top-10 defensive center fielders of all-time, I believe Edmonds would be on that list.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: